Wednesday, September 5, 2007

Two sides of sanctions


Iran and the US both deploy sanctions against each other's citizens; Iran is criticised but the US seems to get away with it.

Hossein Derakhshan

Hossein Derakhshan

September 4, 2007 10:00 AM

On a sunny day in Washington, DC, my imaginary American scholar, Hannah Esfandiari, was sitting in her Kalorama-located house, opening a letter she had just received from Tehran, Iran.

It was a job offer from a prominent think tank at the heart of the Islamic Republic's policy-making machine. Her main job was going to be establishing contacts with Americans dissidents, scholars and activists and inviting them to Tehran to speak to high-ranking Iranian policy-makers, top officers of the Revolutionary Guards and the intelligence ministry.

But she could not take the job offer. Not because she was afraid of being charged with assisting a "state sponsor of terrorism" and perhaps being sent to Guantanamo Bay, but simply because, based on the Iranian Transactions Regulations, it would be illegal for her or any other American to sign any contract with, accept any funds from, or give any service to an Iranian citizen or organisation, wherever in the world. Violating that law could cost her up to 20 years of jail and a $250,000 fine.

Now, let's come back to the real world and consider a similar case about an Iranian citizen who was directing a prominent American think tank.

Haleh Esfandiari's job, as director of the Middle East programme at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars (established by the US Congress in 1981 and co-funded directly by the US government), was to invite Iranian dissidents, scholars and activists to Washington to speak for and interact with high-ranking American policymakers, top military and intelligence officers. (Absent from all media reports is that she has served among the first group of fellows at the controversial National Endowment for Democracy.)

But when she last visited Tehran using her Iranian passport, she was detained, charged with acting against Iran's national security and released on bail after a long investigation.

Read More


No comments:

Post a Comment